I had been meaning for a long time to write down my thoughts about the American Idol winners' tour that I saw about a month ago. We drove to Evansville, IN to see it, which was about six hours away. We had great seats, only about fifty feet or so from the stage, so that worked out well. We were on the floor as well, so that helped the visibility and sound quality. The show worked like this: each person who finished in the top 10 last year was there, including the winner David Cook. Each singer got to do three songs, David Archuleta the second-place contestant did four, and David Cook did four plus an encore. They also did two group numbers. So basically we're talking 37 numbers and something like three and a half hours of music. I had no gripes about getting our money's worth (the seats weren't terribly expensive because we bought them early), but overall I found the whole thing a little too commercialized. There were, however, some truly stand-out performances. Here's what I thought of them:
10th place: Chikezie
Sadly quite boring overall, owing mostly to his lackluster stage presence and awful song choices. So bad, in fact, that I've already forgotten what he even sang. I could look it up, but I don't care enough. Would much rather have traded him for Amanda Overmeyer, the growly Janis-Joplin-yowling nurse that got 11th place.
9th place: Ramiele Malubay
Not as cute in real life as on television, but sounded much better. She did a couple of throw-away pop tunes and then did a rather sweet version of Taylor Dayne's "Love Will Lead You Back" which I enjoyed.
8th place: Michael Johns
This dude really surprised me because I outright hated him on the show. Whatever it was about him that came off badly on television struck exactly the right chord in his live performance. He was energetic, light-hearted, and had a monster of a voice. He tackled "We Are the Champions" effortlessly, "It's All Wrong, But It's All Right" with more bluesy soul than I thought he could manage, and then he finished his set with a face-peeling rendition of Aerosmith's "Dream On" that was arguably the best single number of the night. Yowling falsetto and all. Yes, it was awesome. Not likely that I'll get to hear a full band/stadium version of that time by anyone anytime soon, and Johns really blasted it.
7th place: Kristi Lee Cook
Sounded OK, but rather lifeless overall and sort of phoned it in emotively. "God Bless the USA" played on September 11th was unlikely to fall flat to an audience in Indiana, but I could have done without it.
6th place: Carly Smithson
There was a point during this season when I felt sure that this Irish girl would win the whole thing. It was probably right after she did a legendary sultry bar-band version of "Come Together" on the show. Seeing her in real life, it seemed more appropriate that she finished where she did, but she did have a terrific voice, a fun stage persona, and looked a thousand times better in real life than on television where the camera did not love her. She brought out the second pleasant surprise of the evening with Evanescense's "Bring me to Life" in addition to a decent if not as impressive "Crazy on You". She finished with "I Drove All Night" which was only memorable in my disappointment that she didn't do "Come Together".
5th place: Brooke White
Frankly, should have been in second place. She was much, much more talented than any of the other contestants in the top five except for David Cook himself, who I'll get to in a minute. She played "Let it Be" on the piano, which was gorgeous, and an irritating, forgettable Shania Twain tune. I was all set to be royally pissed off that she didn't do her amazing versions of "You're So Vain" or "Love is a Battlefield", but then she hauled out my second favorite tune of the night, and perhaps the most unexpected pleasant surprise. She did her version of Coldplay's "Yellow" with a full band and a huge star-themed light-show that I found really spellbinding. Her voice took all of the harshness of Chris Martin out of the song and really brought it to life. I'd pay to just see her, if she toured.
4th place: Jason Castro
Turned out to be the biggest disappointment of the evening, because he didn't do "Hallelujah", and instead opted for just "Somewhere over the Rainbow" with a pretty decent Ukelele accompaniment and "Daydream". Oh well. I suppose he's sick to death of singing Hallelujah, but still...
3rd place: Syesha Mercado
Did a cool, if slightly oversexed, version of Rhianna's "Umbrella" and two other forgettable tunes. Decent performer if all she has to do is vamp around to someone else's tunes. Wouldn't be a terrific act on her own.
2nd place: David Archuleta
Let loose a great version of "Angels" by Robbie Williams and a passable version of "Apologize", but then sunk it out with some unknown tune by some irrelevant band and a soggy rendition of "Stand By Me". Voice sounded more than a little crack-ey.
and of course, David Cook the winner of Amercian Idol last year went last.
Cook really proved, I think, that he was always a cut above the others. Brooke White had surprisingly good taste in arrangements and presence, and Michael Johns proved that he had a hundred times more vocal power than I thought he did, but David Cook delivered almost exactly what you would think he would: just a terrific, seasoned, nuanced, and talented set from someone who was, is, and will be a star. He did Aerosmith's "Don't Want To Miss A Thing", His own single "The Time of My Life", Lionel Richie's "Hello", The Foo Fighters' "My Hero", and finished with "Billie Jean" as his encore.
And if that wasn't enough, while he was pulling the walls down on the stadium with "Billie Jean" someone sitting right in front of me had her purse stolen while we were all waving our cell phones and screaming our heads off.
Stay classy, Indiana!